Great reasons to be a guinea pig
Wednesday, July 15, 2009

Huntington’s disease is a 100-percent genetic condition, so, because I tested positive for this brain disorder, I have no control over its cause. I will develop symptoms. After receiving my test results ten years ago, I could have gone into a cocoon or committed suicide or lived in reckless abandon. Instead, I decided to control what I could.

I became active in all senses of the word: watching my health, raising awareness about HD, participating in the local support group, and, as an activist for HDSA-San Diego, doing my small part in the effort to find treatments and a cure.

I have also taken part in numerous experiments designed to bring scientists a clearer understanding of the disease. I basically have become a guinea pig in procedures that are often repetitive, tiring, and sometimes downright boring.

They can also be very intimidating, because they force me to focus on my medical situation when I’d rather be doing something else.

But these experiments are vitally important for preparing the way for effective clinical trials. To see if a potential treatment is working, researchers must have a baseline of information about HD symptoms, including the practically imperceptible early signs of the disease in gene-positive individuals like me.

In fact, because of a shortage of test subjects, Huntington’s clinicians have been sounding the alarm for the need for more at-risk and affected individuals to join the experiments and also current and upcoming clinical trials for potential drugs.

Dr. Martha Nance, the director of the HDSA Center of Excellence in Minneapolis, has noted in a recent article that the lack of willing research subjects will “delay the development of new treatments for HD.” Similarly, Dr. LaVonne Goodman, the founder and director of the Huntingtons Disease Drug Works program (HDDW), has written that clinical trials “will accomplish little if we don’t take the next steps to maximize participation” (click here to read Dr. Goodman's article).

Many experiments, much information

I began the experiments after learning in 1995 that my mother had Huntington’s. I gave blood to be screened for the genetic defect. At that time I took the first in a series of occasional batteries of neuropsychological tests, which involve memorizing words, comparing objects drawn on paper, distinguishing the names of colors from actual colors, and other kinds of mental exercises. I have also lain for hours in functional MRI machines that took images of my brain as I slept or as I played a kind of video game with my fingers.

Scientists have even established that gene-positive individuals will suffer changes in their sense of smell. Accordingly, I took part in an experiment where I spent a long time sampling and identifying different smells of small amounts of substances presented to me in tiny cups.

I have also responded to questionnaires for the National Research Roster for Huntingtons Disease Patients and Families, a three-decade-old study of HD families headquartered at the University of Indiana.

And I am a participant in HDDW. I take HDDW supplements every day (the sugar trehalose, coenzyme Q-10, Omega-3 fish oil pills, blueberry concentrate, and creatine) in the hopes of staving off symptoms. I am required to do a periodic battery of tests on my home computer, such as tapping keys and performing mental exercises similar to the neuropsychological tests described above. In effect, I’ve been participating in a clinical trial of a kind of HD cocktail.

Testing my balance

The importance of the experiments and the stresses involved weighed upon my mind on July 13 as I took part in yet another experimental session, this one at San Diego State University.
The entrance to the lab at San Diego State University (photo by HDSA-San Diego)

The experiment focused on my motor control – the ability to move in a coordinated manner and to maintain stability. I had participated in the first phase of this experiment a year ago, and this latest session aimed to see if there was any change in my situation.

Like most of the other experiments, it was designed to see if I am showing any symptoms of the disease so early and so slight that only a machine or a computer can detect.
 

The finger sensors (photo by HDSA-San Diego)

First, I had to listen to about 60 beeps on a speaker and tap one of my fingers on a sensor in synch with each beep. A computer recorded my reactions for the research assistant in charge of the experiment.

I knew the experiment would probably include a test of this kind, so I prepared carefully in the morning. I didn’t want to do my daily stretch but did anyway in order to be as limber as possible, thus allowing me to have good posture and maximum dexterity.

I sat before the two sensors – one for the right hand, the other for the left – like a sprinter the moment before the starting gun is fired in the 100-yard dash. At first I made mistakes and did not keep up the tapping after the beeps had stopped, as the instructions had required. By the end I was trying to anticipate the first beep in order to make my first tap at the same time.

Outsmarting Huntington’s

As in other experiments, I needed to prove to myself that I had no symptoms. I strived to match the machine’s impulses as closely as possible. And, I thought, if I do have symptoms, I wanted my brain to compensate for them with the total concentration and energy I was devoting to the experiment.

A research assistant demonstrates the use of the balancing device (photo by HDSA-San Diego).

Like the man who uses his intelligence to control his schizophrenia in the film A Beautiful Mind, I want to believe that I can outsmart these machines and ultimately Huntington’s disease itself.

In the next room I stood on the platform of a device used to measure balance. The SMART Balance Master, made by NeuroCom International, Inc., consisted of foot plates and surrounding scenery that both moved. The research assistant strapped me into a safety harness that would catch me in case I fell. In various tests, with my eyes opened and closed, I had to maintain my balance as the computer recorded reactions through foot sensors.

I kept my balance with little effort and without the need of the harness. But I thought of how terrifying an experience such a machine would present to a Huntingon’s disease patient such as my mother, who died of the disease in 2006. In the last few years of her life she fell a number of times, once breaking a wrist, another time suffering a large gash on her head that required several staples. She would have found it practically impossible to remain standing in this machine, even though the movements are quite manageable for the normal person, akin to jerking motions on an escalator.

I did not ask the research assistant if he had detected any subtle symptoms of HD in my tests. I was not interested in such information, preferring instead to think that I had easily passed.

I need to continue thinking of myself as an asymptomatic at-risk individual. To learn that symptoms had started might prove too devastating to me at this time.

A sense of accomplishment

I ended the experiments with a sense of relief. I had once again stared down Huntington’s disease and, at least as far as I can tell, came away the victor.

As I look back on the day and the many other experiments in which I have participated, I have a deep feeling of satisfaction at having contributed to the gathering of knowledge about the disease.

The discomfort of having to think about HD and my mother’s demise is an extremely small price to pay for helping prepare for the day when treatments could help me and thousands of other at-risk individuals avoid early symptoms.

By participating in experiments, I’ll also be keeping myself properly informed about treatments as they become ready.

Everybody can help

Testing centers urgently need more subjects to take part in their experiments and clinical trials. Everybody can help: patients, at-risk individuals, relatives, and friends. Even if you and your family are not affected by HD, you can encourage affected families to participate and help ease the burden by driving them to the testing centers or assisting in other ways. Please contact HDSA or your HDSA chapter or Center of Excellence to learn more.

Those of us touched by HD cannot change our genetic reality, but together we can help build the mass of knowledge that will help scientists select the right treatments and fine-tune them so that people of all levels of risk and disease can benefit.

 

Tags: Huntington's disease, Huntington's, genetic, tested positive, brain, symptoms, suicie, activist, HDSA-San Diego, HDSA, experiments, clinical trials, scientists, guinea pig, gene-positive, at-risk, affected, drugs, Martha Nance, LaVonne Goodman, Huntington's Disease Drug Works, HDDW, mother, defect, MRI, National Research Roster, trehalose, coenzyme Q-10, omega, fish oil, blueberry, creatine, neuropsychological, cocktail, motor control, stability, A Beautiful Mind, balance, asymptomatic, treatments, Center of Excellence

Comments

Great Overview and Personal Outlook
Thank you for your honesty, persistence, and willingness to continue to educate the HD community and beyond.. It's important that we understand that there is a process, and real consequences to the choices we make. Though it is difficult to accept and adapt to such unthinkable conditions with HD, it helps to understand what role we can play in making a difference. In order to understand that role, I believe we need to know what to expect, and how our participation will matter. You've shared some very important things here, and it was a pleasure reading this. I'm posting this to my FB Group site to direct them to your blogs. Susan
Wednesday, March 3, 2010 04:26 PM by Susan Lawrence

Post a Comment
= Required
Name:
Email Address:
Title:
Detail:
Archive
Words Used in Gene’s Blog
Words are scaled by number of uses. Click on a word to trace its use in blog entries.
"can do" spirit    9/11    A Beautiful Mind    abortion    accident    accountability    activism    activist    advocacy    advocate    advocates    affected    AIDS    Alice Wexler    ALN-HTT    Alnylam    Alzheimer's    America    anonymity    anonymous    antisense    anxiety    Apollo    assisted suicide    Associação Brasil Huntington    asymptomatic    at risk    at-risk    at-risk status    attitude    awareness    balance    battles    BDNF    behavioral    belief    Bible    biomarker    biotech    biotechnology    blessing    blog    blueberry    Bonnie Hennig    brain    Brazil    brother    Bush    CAG repeats    CalAsia Pharmaceuticals    California    came out    cancer    care    care facility    Care2Cure    caregiver    caregiving    carrier    catholic    Catholicism    cells    Center of Excellence    cerebral    Chargers    Charles Sabine    CHDI    CHDI Foundation    child    China    chorea    Christ    Christian    Christianity    CIRM    civil rights    clinic    clinical trial    clinical trials    Clinton    closet    cocktail    code    coenzyme Q-10    cognitive    cognitive decline    COHORT    collective    come out    coming out    compassion    Congress    conscious    consciousness    cope    coping    creatine    cross    cure    cure industry    cycle of life    Darwin    daughter    death    decline    defect    defective    dehydrated    dementia    denial    depressed    depression    DFS    diagnosis    diet    Differential Fragment-Based Screening    Dinah Sah    disability    disabled    discrimination    disease    disorder    DNA    doctor    donor    drug    drug discovery    drug hunter    drug pipeline    drugs    dysfunction    easter    economic crisis    Edgemoor    Egypt    emotions    energy    Enroll-HD    escapism    eugenics    evil    evolution    exercise    experiment    experiments    faceless    faith    families    family    fantasize    Fastlane    fatal    father    FDA    fear    feeding tube    fight    financial crisis    finger-tapping    fish oil    Flash of Genius    football    forsaken    Francis Collins    freedom    fundraising    gene    gene positive    gene silencing    gene-negative    gene-positive    generation    genetic    genetic counseling    genetic defect    genetic mirror    genetic test    genetic testing    geneticist    Genome    Genome Project    genomic    get tested    Giamatti    God    going public    Good Friday    granddaughter    grandfather    grandmother    grief    guinea pig    Guthrie    H.R. 678    HD    HD Buzz    HD closet    HD war chest    HD warrior    HD-affected    HD-free    HD-negative    HD-positive    HDDW    HDSA    HDSA Person of the Year    HDSA-San Diego    health    health care    health care reform    healthy    Hereditary Disease Foundation    Holy Week    honesty    hope    horror    House    House Bill 678    HSG    humanity    huntingtin    huntingtin suppression    huntington's    Huntington's disease    Huntington's Disease Advocacy Center    Huntington's Disease Drug Works    Huntington's warrior    hurricane    hurtling towards death    husband    ignorance    immobility    incurable    India    innovation    instinct    Institute for Regenerative Cures    insurance    Interstate Highway System    inventors    Isaac Asimov    Isis    Isis Pharmaceuticals    israelite    It's a Bird    Jan Nolta    Jesuit    Jesus    Jim Calhoun    Jody Corey-Bloom    Johns Hopkins University    juggling    juvenile HD    juvenile Huntington's    juvenile Huntington's disease    Katie Moser    Keith Elliston    knowledge    lab    laser-guided missile    Latin America    LaVonne Goodman    leadership    legacy    Leslie Thompson    lessons    Lessons from the Ancients    Lou Gehrig's    Louise Vetter    love    Lundbeck    Maracaibo    marathon    marriage    Marshall Plan    Martha Nance    mask    meaning    Medi-Cal    Medicaid    Medicare    medication    meditation    medium spiny neuron    Medtronic    memory    mercy killing    mesenchymal stem cell    metabolic    Michael Hayden    mind    mind coach    misfold    mitochondria    modifier gene    mood    mood swings    morale    mortality    mother    motor    motor control    motor skills    MRI    mutant    mutation    mysticism    Nancy Wexler    nation    National Football League    National Institutes of Health    National Research Roster    negative    nervous    Neurobic    neurogenesis    neurological    neurologist    neuron    neuropsychological    neuroscience    neuroscientists    newsletter    NINDS    noosphere    nursing home    Obama    observational study    observational trial    oligonucleotide    oligonucleotides    omega    omega-3    onset    orphan    orphan disease    outburst    outsourced    Pacifici    Parity Act    Parkinson's    passover    patient    persevere    personalized medicine    PGD    Ph.D.    pharmaceutical    Phase I    Phase II    Phase III    Phebe Hedges    polyglutamine    positive    positive test    pre-existing condition    pre-manifest    PREDICT-HD    pregnancy    premanifest    presymptomatic    privacy    Promised Land    protein    psychiatric    psychiatrist    psychoanalyst    psychologist    psychologists    psychology    psychotherapist    psychotherapy    psychotic    public    pump    Race Across America    ravaged    receptor    reflection    rehabilitation facility    relationship    relaxing    religion    religious traditions    research    researcher    Resurrection    Rhes    risk    ritual    RNA    RNA interference    RNAi    Robert Pacifici    Robi Blumenstein    San Diego    science    scientist    scientists    Scripps Research Institute    seizure    sex    shaking    Shoot to Cure HD    Shriver    side effect    siRNA    sister    sleep    smell    social justice    Social Security    solidarity    son    soul    Spanish    spirit    spiritual    spirituality    sports    stability    stem cell    stem-cell    stem-cell oversight    sterilization    sterilize    Steven Seagle    stigma    strength    stress    striatum    stroke    struggle    success    suffering    suicide    suicie    supplement    supplements    support    support group    supporters    survival    swim    swimming    sympathy    symptomatic    symptoms    synapse    synaptic dysfunction    sypmtoms    technology    Teilhard    Terry Leach    test    tested    tested negative    tested positive    testing    testing positive    tetrabenazine    theology    therapeutic    therapist    therapy    Thich Nhat Hanh    time bomb    tinkerers    togetherness    tongue    TRACK-HD    transitions    treatment    treatments    trehalose    trial    trials    trinucleotide    truth    UCSD    UHDRS    unemployment    untested    urgency    Venezuela    Vertex    Wall-E    warrior    WeAreHD.org    website    wheelchair    wife    workaholic    Xenazine    Yale